What is Human Trafficking

Know the Facts

Know the Facts

What is Human Trafficking

Let’s clear up the common misconception that human smuggling and human trafficking mean the same thing. These commonly conflated terms are not the same.

Human smuggling is where a person voluntarily pays to be transported illegally to a new country and is free from the smuggler upon arrival [1]. Note that human smuggling can turn into human trafficking if an individual is smuggled into another country and then held captive or exploited on their arrival [1].

Human trafficking is when a person is manipulated, controlled, and/or forced to do things against their will (e.g. being forced into sex work). They are exploited in some way to benefit someone else [1].

There are different types of human trafficking (e.g. labour trafficking, organ trafficking, etc). This resource will focus on human trafficking for the purpose of sexual exploitation (i.e. sex trafficking) and any reference to ‘human trafficking’ herein refers specifically to sex trafficking.

Note: Sex work and sex trafficking are different. In sex work, a person:

  • Has made a choice to enter the sex trade
  • Has control over their working conditions (e.g. they control the types of services they provide, how many clients they see in a day, etc)
  • Has control over their own profits
  • Is not controlled by someone else
  • Can choose to stop engaging in sex work at any time

This is not the case for individuals who are being sex trafficked [2]. 

Due to the often complex relationship that exists between a trafficked individual and their trafficker (or “pimp”), some may not even realize that they are being trafficked [3] and they may have their situation confused with sex work.

What is Human Trafficking
Source: MCIS Language Solutions (helpingtraffickedpersons.org)

Note: Recruiting anyone under the age of 18 years old for the purpose of sexual exploitation is considered sex trafficking, even if no coercion or deception was involved. Those under 18 have special legal status and CANNOT consent to engage in sex work [4].

Know the Facts

Who does Human Trafficking happen to?

Human trafficking can happen to anyone from any socioeconomic background, race, gender, culture or age group. While 95% of reported cases in Canada involve women and girls, sex trafficking can and does happen to men and boys in Canada [1,4].

Most reported cases involve trafficked individuals who are Canadian-born women and girls between the ages of 18 and 24 years old [1]. According to Statistics Canada, over 45% of victims identified by police are under age 25 [1]. Certain groups tend to be at higher risk including [1,4]:

Young women and girls

  • Indigenous women and girls
  • Youth in care
  • Those with mental health and addiction issues
  • New immigrants
  • Homeless youth
  • LGBTQ+ youth

According to the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP), in recent years, individuals with relatively stable backgrounds are becoming increasingly targeted [8].

What is Human Trafficking - Know the Facts

What are some of the Human Trafficking risk factors?

Although there is no standard “profile” for a sex trafficked individual, the following factors make individuals more susceptible to victimization:

  • Mental health issues
  • Body image issues
  • Low self-esteem
  • Learning disabilities
  • Social isolation
  • Abuse or lack of support in the family
  • Violence in the home
  • Poverty and a need for survival
An individual may have a desire for a better life – maybe they wish for the supportive family life that they’ve never had, money, nice clothing, or just someone to tell them that they are beautiful. Traffickers prey on an individual’s vulnerabilities to lure and manipulate them. They scope out people who are vulnerable, naive and trusting and lure them with things like expensive gifts, the promise of affection, a glamorous lifestyle, etc. [6].

Know the Facts

How does it happen? it may not happen how you think...

What is Human Trafficking and How does it Happen?

Many tend to think that an individual is forced into sex trafficking by being forcefully abducted or drugged – although this does happen – the more common scenario involves a trafficker tricking a vulnerable person into trusting them by forming a relationship. The trafficker may pretend to be kind or in love in order to lure a vulnerable person into sex trafficking (this type of trafficker is sometimes called a “Romeo Pimp” or “Boyfriend Pimp”). 

The process often consists of luring, grooming, coercion and manipulation, and ultimately sexual exploitation [13]. In this section we refer to the trafficked individual as ‘she’ and the trafficker as ‘he’ as this is often the case; however, both traffickers and trafficked individuals can be any gender.

Luring: 

Sex Traffickers tend to connect with people directly or through mutual friends or acquaintances. This can occur anywhere, especially where youth hang out: schools, shopping malls, parties, fast food restaurants, youth facilities/shelters, the internet, etc [6].

Snapchat and Instagram are noted by Waterloo Regional Police as common tools used by traffickers. Social media can be relatively anonymous, so if a trafficker targets an individual online, sends them a private message and they are not receptive, the trafficker can easily slip back into anonymity and look for someone else to target. ​

​Some traffickers get teens to recruit in high schools by befriending the potential victim [13], or they may set up bogus job interviews to make contact with unsuspecting, vulnerable people [14]. Recruitment can also happen at parties and social gatherings; in some cases, girls who are working with traffickers or girls who are trafficked themselves are forced to recruit at parties (in other words, victims are forced to victimize others). The trafficker starts by forming a connection with someone and collects as much information as possible about them to use against them later on [13].

Grooming: 

The trafficker may make a girl feel like a princess and she thinks that she is in love and has found the man of her dreams. He often makes false promises of providing things like a family or a home. He may make her feel special by taking her out shopping, to get her hair and nails done, etc. They may engage in physical intimacy and often she is led to believe that he is her boyfriend [13].

Coercion and Manipulation: 
Once a strong sense of attachment and dependency is formed he starts sending mixed messages. By shifting between acting caring and being threatening, he maintains psychological control [14]. She feels both loyal and intimidated [14]. He begins to ask her to do sexual acts that she may be uncomfortable with or to pay her for sexual acts – gradually desensitizing her to these actions and getting her used to the idea that sex comes with a price.

He may use the information he gained about her to maintain control (e.g. reminding her that he knows where her family members live, etc). She grows more and more dependent on him and feels like she has to follow the rules he sets out [9]. He may move her away from her home to hotels/motels [15], ensuring that she is disoriented and without resources [14].

Exploitation: 
Her self-esteem is completely shattered. He threatens her and her loved ones, using the information he knows about her [13]. She feels that she owes him and is obligated to contribute financially. She is withstanding emotional, mental and often-times physical abuse all resulting in intimidation and control. She is forced to perform sex acts for customers, and she sees little or none of the profits. She is alone, isolated and has no control of her situation and feels that there is no way of getting out. She is trapped in a life of exploitation [13].

Know the Facts

Key Terms

  • What is Human trafficking? Human Trafficking is when a person is manipulated, controlled, and/or forced to do things against their will (e.g. being forced into sex work). They are exploited in some way to benefit someone else [2].
  • International human trafficking: Involves someone, who in the process of being trafficked, crosses an international border, regardless of the victim’s immigration status [12].
  • Domestic human trafficking: When an individual is trafficked within the borders of a country, regardless of the victim’s legal status [12].
  • Human smuggling: A person voluntarily pays to be transported illegally to a new country, and is free from the smuggler upon arrival [1].
  • Coercion: Persuading someone to do something using threats. 
  • Exploitation: Treating someone unfairly in order to take advantage of them. 
  • Romeo/Boyfriend Pimp: A trafficker who pretends to be in love in order to lure a vulnerable person into sex trafficking.

Know the Facts

References

  1. A Handbook for Criminal Justice Practitioners on Trafficking in Persons, January 2024, Federal/Provincial/Territorial -Working Group on Trafficking in Persons. Available online at: https://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/rp-pr/cj-jp/tp/hcjpotp2-gtpupjp2/index.html
  2. Kids Help Phone. What is Human Trafficking? Available online at: https://kidshelpphone.ca/get-info/what-human-trafficking/
  3. MCIS Language Solutions. General Training on Human Trafficking for Service Providers, Online Training Initiative to Address Human Trafficking. Available online at: http://helpingtraffickedpersons.org/
  4. Trafficking in persons in Canada, 2020 by Shana Conroy and Danielle Sutton, Canadian Centre for Justice and Community Safety Statistics. Available online at: https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/85-002-x/2022001/article/00010-eng.htm
  5. Government of Ontario, Women’s Directorate, 2016. Strategy to End Human Trafficking – Overview of Initiatives. Available online at: https://news.ontario.ca/en/backgrounder/40986/strategy-to-end-human-trafficking-overview-of-initiatives
  6. Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) Human Trafficking National Coordination Center, 2012. Youth Toolkit – “I’m Not For Sale”. Available online at: https://www.publicsafety.gc.ca/cnt/rsrcs/pblctns/ntnl-ctn-pln-cmbt-prgrss-2013/index-en.aspx
  7. Rising Angels Awareness & Restorative Care, 2017. Mending Broken Wings – A Resource Manual for Working with Survivors of Commercial Sexual Exploitation. 
  8. The Globe & Mail, 2016. The Trafficked: How Sex Trafficking Works in Canada. Available online at: https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/the-trafficked-how-sex-trafficking-works-in-canada/article28700689/
  9. Timea Nagy et al, 2018. Guide for Parents on Domestic Sex Trafficking. 
  10. Government of Canada, 2018. National Action Plan to Combat Human Trafficking. Available online at: https://www.publicsafety.gc.ca/cnt/rsrcs/pblctns/ntnl-ctn-pln-cmbt/ntnl-ctn-pln-cmbt-eng.pdf.
  11. Ontario Women’s Justice Network, 2018. What is human trafficking? Available online at: http://owjn.org/2018/06/what-is-human-trafficking
  12. RCMP, 2012. National Strategy to Combat Human Trafficking. Available online at: http://publications.gc.ca/collections/collection_2014/grc-rcmp/PS64-104-2012-eng.pdf
  13. Its Time to T.A.L.K about Sex trafficking, Canadian Center to End Human Trafficing. Available online at: https://www.canadianhumantraffickinghotline.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/Its-Time-to-T.A.L.K.pdf
  14. Covenant House Toronto, 2018. Sex Trafficking. Available online at: https://www.covenanthousetoronto.ca/homeless-youth/Sex-Trafficking. Accessed 25-Nov-2018.
  15. UNODC, 2008. Toolkit to Combat Trafficking in Persons. Available online at: https://www.unodc.org/documents/human-trafficking/HT_Toolkit08_English.pdf.
  16. Statistics Canada, 2018. Trafficking in Persons in Canada, 2016. Available online at: https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/85-005-x/2018001/article/54979-eng.htm